Green Aid in India and Zimbabwe – conserving whose community?

by Zoe Young, George Makoni, Sonja Boehmer-Christiansen, Department of Geography, University of Hull, 2001

What happens when global institutions try to assist community conservation in some of the world’s least industrialised areas? Among the cutting edge' projects grant-aided by the Global Environment Facility (GEF, a World Bank-hosted fund for global environmental benefits’) are CAMPFIRE' – the Communal Areas Management Programme For Indigenous Resources – in Zimbabwe, and India Ecodevelopment’. Both are intended to combine protection of biodiverse wildlife with participatory rural development for impoverished local communities. We explore the ground truths' of these projects in two historical and political contexts. We ask whether aspiring managers of global resources’ can sufficiently transcend ongoing tensions in local political ecology', while diverse value systems and experiences remain distant. We conclude with thoughts about the sustainable development’ of foreign missions old and new.